Edinburgh Fringe 2004 home

Week 3 - 22nd - 28th August

In places this week was rather dead, in others it was frenetic as people scrambled to catch the shows they didn't want to miss before leaving. The Edinburgh weather wasn't especially kind and I'm fairly certain the Olympics hadn't done audience numbers any favours.

At some point this week, my co-performer in The Musical! and I decided to catch a night of shows, rather than dwell on the misery of the "other venue". That night was on 26th August and it was very enjoyable! In the end, though, we found ourselves drifting into the free shows in our own main venue (they were free to us) that needed supportive audience members. It was eclectic.

On 27th August, I made the mistake of watching a very good show (Stewart Lee) followed by two bad ones. Couple this with the sense that the Fringe was soon to end, and I hit my lowest point in the Fringe. I'm not listing the second of the bad shows from that date as I left before I'd seen too much of it.

Show

Review

22nd August

 
17.30 - This was/were your life(s)
***
Nicol Edwards
A curious mockumentary about a couple of characters that I cannot remember a great deal about, some two years later. In places these show wove comedic gold out of nothing, in other places it was, as is the nature of the mockumentary, fairly self-serving.

Overall, though, this was a show that the Fringe is built upon - it could only exist in the world of Fringe theatre, and I was glad to have seen it.

 

00.00 - Late Show
**
Nicol Edwards
I was involved with countless late night comedy showcases at this venue over the course of the Fringe. Often I was either compereing or doing a set. On this one occasion I sat and watched the show. The whole thing can be summed up thus:

"What do you get when you cross an exhausted, disinterested audience, who have paid no money, with a bunch of lack-lustre comedians who are prepared to play for free?"

 

23rd August

 
20.30 - Richard Herring - The Twelve Trials of Hercules Terrace
****
Pod Deco
Seeing Richard Herring at the Fringe is a very important part of a Fringe experience, in my opinion. This year's show told the story of what happens to a man who goes through various crises as he tries to adjust to his lot in life. Richard's solution was to set himself a series of literally Herculean tasks. A lot of the show involved telling the story and finding the funny within.

The show was clearly larger than the timeslot provided and the modest audience would have been prepared to stay longer and hear more of the story, or hear less of it at less than breakneck pace.

However, hurtling through the tale with laughs along the way did us all just fine and the somewhat overly-produced wrap-up at the end was what the story probably needed, even if it did jar a bit with the overall style of the show.

 

22.00 - Janey Godley Is Innocent
****
Underbelly
Janey Godley went on stage for an hour and told stories about her life. She has had a colourful life, marked by the death of her mother, being the victim of child-abuse, marrying into a Glaswegian gangster family and challenging the establishment along the way. None of this should be funny, but Janey is an intense story teller who takes misfortune and makes us understand it through her natural wit.

Even her introduction to the show, which was nothing more than an excuse for why she was croaky, was the source of much laughter.

I spent most of the show leaning forward on the edge of my seat because I wanted to hear more.

 

26th August

 
20.05 - Mark Maier, Objects
***
Underbelly
Mark Maier is from the North East. We went to see his show because he was a fellow Underbelly act (thus free) and out of some loyalty to our region. In his hour, Mark explored his relationships with objects in the world. Though some of the points might have already been made before - like why men believe they can wait another service stop on a motorway when the car says it's already out of petrol. However, a large part of the art of stand-up is to be able to take any subject and make a personal view on it. Mark could certainly do that, relating it all back to his own history and, ultimately, stupidity.

When we thought this was just going to be stand-up, we turned out to be wrong. In suitable places, Mark impersonated the various objects which blight his life and brought the story to life for us.

With strong performing skills and a finale which involved the audience throwing socks into a bin for good luck, this was a strong show which deserved greater audience support.

 

21.20 - Congress of Oddities
****
Underbelly
See the previous review. I dragged my co-performer into this show and we both emerged glad that I had.

 

22.40 - Alice Lunt's Picnic
***
Underbelly
This show had been getting depressingly low audience figures and we were asked to join some people who were going along to support it. When the cost of supporting a show is nothing, it's hard to find a reason not to go. In addition, I'd met Rosie (one of the cast) before and she seemed like a nice person whose show I'd want to support.

So, in we went for a bemusing hour. There's no doubt that there were some sketches in there, but in places they were mystifying. There's no doubt that the performances were strong - indeed, the cast were the best part about the show. The whole thing was stitched together by the fibres of some fake-twisted-version-of-kids'-TV but I can't quite work out how or why.

Overall, it passed us over, while some of the other supporters hooted with joy.

 

23.55 - 4.2 Tolerance
**
Underbelly
This was another undersubscribed show. Jay Sodagar and Juliette Meyers performed 30 minutes of stand-up each. In their own right both Jay and Juliette are accomplished stand-up comedians. I would not have put them at the standard required to delight a midnight crowd, both being rather more wry and under-stated than hilarious.

They had stitched the show together around the rather flimsy framework of racial tolerance. Jay is Asian and Juliette is Jewish. It's no surprise that they'd each have something to say on the subject of racism. The sad thing, however, is that they didn't have anything surprising or interesting to say on that subject. Indeed, Jay's suggestion of converting "P*ki jokes" into "Racist Jokes" was possibly the most original, yet the least satisfying - turning the derogatory attack on ethnic groups into an attack on the racists might seem like fun, but it feels at hateful as racism - "How do you stop a racist from drowning? Take your foot off his head."

Not many laughs then.

However, Juliette has a quirky charm about her stage persona, and Jay is a very charismatic performer. Both can do better and probably will.

 

27th August

 
20.40 - Stewart Lee
*****
Underbelly
Sychophantic though it may be to award one of my comedy heroes with the only 5 stars I've given in this Fringe's review, I'm still going to do it. With his return to stand-up comedy, Stewart Lee reminded the world how it's supposed to be done. His cliche-free approach to the art is lesson to all aspiring comedians, and the fact that he had something to say, and was prepared to deliver it at his pace, extracting the most comedy from every idea was all the more impressive.

I've since bought this show on DVD and it is a truly triumphant piece of writing and performing.

We were doing our show in this room, which was packed out for Stewart's show (rather than a third full for ours). So, I had the strange experience of sitting in familiar surroundings with my own mirror ball motor running above my head, sharing a row with Harry Hill, while watching Stewart do his thing. I'm glad I hung around the box office as long as it took to wangle the ticket. I had to pay for this ticket, despite having a venue pass, as the show was a sell out. The only reason I got in at all, was because the box office staff, knowing me, were prepared to let me have one of the very special reserved seats, provided nobody else in the venue management needed it.

I should have made it my business to see this show sooner.

 

23.20 - Roger Strokes - Live and Ungloved
minus 1*
Underbelly
From the best show on the Fringe to the worst, then. We went to see this show in order to support the techie who had so successfully run our own show for us nearly every day. (He was successful every time, but didn't come on one particular day.)

Basically, we were told that this show was bad. We thought it couldn't be that bad. Joined by another act using the venue, we sat away from the paying punters and watched the horror unfold.

In fairness to the paying punters, who had no doubt come on the basis of the publicity, which claimed the act was a Perrier Nominee (which he had been under a different guise), they did their best to make the show work, while we cynically sat, arms folded, and tried not to throw up. Given that we'd not paid for tickets, we felt it would be unfair to stage a walk-out, so we sat through the whole thing. We'll never get that hour of our lives back.

While the performer playing Roger Strokes was clearly capable of holding a room and delivering a script, the whole script was one poor joke after another. Largely based around puns and tacky seaside-postcard humour, the premise was that Roger Strokes, a psychic, was going to "come into" the audience, psychically.

With audience interaction pieces that were butt-clenchingly embarrassing, rather than funny, and a finale which involved Roger stripping down to his incontinence pants and simulating sex with a member of the audience, this show was an aberration against the Fringe and deserves its score of negative 1 stars.

Booooo!

Shows/events seen this week: 10
Total so far: 25

>> Week 4

Written: 29 May 2006
Ashley Frieze